Mayor Rob Ford has dodged another legal bullet, after Toronto’s compliance audit committee decided not to prosecute him for violating campaign finance rules.
The three-member committee voted 2-1 to accept the audit report, which concluded hie broke the Municipal Elections Act, but against proceedings to prosecute him.
After the decision, Ford said, “I’m happy this is over. This is a great day for democracy.”
On Feb. 1, a forensic audit of Ford’s finances for his 2010 mayoral campaign showed he broke the Municipal Elections Act when he exceeded the authorized spending limit of $1.3 million. The analysis, conducted by Froese Forensic Partners Ltd., found the Ford team overspent by $40,168.
On Monday, the three-person committee heard from lawyers for both sides as well as forensic expert Bruce Armstrong, who wrote the report.
Heidi Rubin, the lawyer for Adam Chaleff-Freudenthaler and Max Reed, who filed the complaint, said pleading ignorance of election laws was unacceptable for someone in the mayor’s position.
“When a fifth-time candidate violates election laws to the extent shown by the auditors’ findings, it must be in the public interest to see the matter forward to the prosecution,” she said.
Rubin cited findings in relation to an event at the Grand Baccus which was put on by the mayor in 2010. Ford said the event, which cost about $27,000 to host, was a fundraiser, not a promotional event which would have been subject to a spending limit. However Rubin noted that the auditor found that less than $3,000 in fundraising revenue was raised during that event.
The mayor’s lawyer Tom Barlow told the committee that the funds raised during the event were not incidental but that the evening was more about making contacts to be used for fundraising at a later date.
“For this event, the campaign saw getting people in the door and getting their personal information as part of the fundraising activity,” he said. “They raised $2,900 that night and then, as you saw in our submissions, from those people who attended that event, by following up on them they raised approximately $14,000 more. So for an event that cost $27,796.29 they raised almost $16,000 in contributions.”
He added that all money raised at the event were properly recorded, which showed the intent for transparency in the campaign.
Although Barlow acknowledged some mistakes had been made during the campaign, he said that they were simply oversights and that lessons had been learned through these proceedings.
“There’s no such thing as perfection in life and there’s certainly no such thing as perfection in election law and there is also, generally speaking, no such thing as perfection in accounting,” he said. “The buck does stop here in my submission. You’re in a position to assess the situation as any prosecutor.”
The audit was ordered after Chaleff-Freudenthaler and Reed alleged Ford exceeded his spending limit. They also claimed he broke the law by borrowing $77,722 for his campaign from his family’s company, Doug Ford Holdings Inc.
Earlier this month, the committee voted unanimously to start legal proceedings against Coun. Giorgio Mammoliti after a forensic audit found he exceeded his campaign spending limit by about $12,000.
This was the third victory for the mayor who faced three lawsuits in the past year.
In December, a judge rejected a $6-million defamation lawsuit by Beach restaurant owner George Foulidis, who sued Ford over comments made during the campaign.
Last year, Paul Magder launched a conflict-of-interest lawsuit against the mayor over $3,150 donated to Ford’s football charity, which the city’s integrity commissioner said was solicited using city resources and violated the province’s Conflict of Interest Act.
In November, Ontario Superior Court Justice Charles Hackland ruled against Ford in the case and he was ordered out of office. The decision was overturned last month by an Ontario Divisional Court panel.
Ford is launching legal action against Magder to recoup about $116,000 in legal fees.
Magder’s lawyer, Clayton Ruby, said his client plans to file an appeal with the Supreme Court of Canada.
- with files from Shawne McKeown and Erin Criger

Ok as a citizen can i launch a lawsuit against 5 or so Councillors i dislike too? I mean it’s the norm now. Why weren’t there all these lawsuits and media attention for Miller, Lastman etc.
If a black person committed a crime, then would anyone have the authority to vote to not prosecute him/her?
Carry on Ford.
Congratulations Rob Ford! I know you want to save the taxpayers money and are doing a good job so keep the momentum! Forget those losers who just want to waste your time and tax payers money trying to find fault with everything, they need to look in the mirror.
ZZ: You lose again, it’s time to move on and let the ELECTED mayor do his job.
Maybe you should focus on the UNELECTED Premier who’s currently wrapped up in one of the biggest scandals ever, a REAL scandal.
SMH.
I’m am so confused, if Adam Vaughan is so pure and such a great person he will open up his finances to prove he has nothing to hide ! Go on Adam open up your books show us that you are just the best person ever. OR wait what is that, you can’t cause you spend the tax payers money just to try and slow down the mayor. Who is trying to cut wasteful spending in this city !! Say it isn’t so Adam you cry fowl every chance you get cause the Mayor is doing what he set out to do! I mean you look like the little spoiled kid on the playground. How about you take your balls and go home you idiot. Its time the city moves forward and leaves you behind. You can’t stand that a politician actually backs his words. I mean you are the biggest two faced rat bastard to every get elected Adam. Show us what good you have done !!! I really mean someone tell me one good thing he has accomplished.
I agree, and you know what if that side of the fence keeps organizing citizens and provoke citizens to file complaints on Ford, obviously someone would need to prove this, then Adam would face some legal heat. Adam likes this kind of media drama on Ford. Adam, how about front row tickets to a new drama, it’s playing at the downtown provincial criminal courthouse. It begins with citizens laying an information for Public nuisance and conspiracy to commit. I think politicians should be ban from inciting citizens to file complaints on other parties. I think the feds need to step in now and intervien and ask these complainers to see who they were bribed by. I’d start with a search warrant on Adam Vaughn’s cell phone records, texts, and VM.
What balls. He’s another gelded Liberal!
And the BEST mayor EVER, wins again. Great job Rob.You are too tough for these losers. You will always get our families votes!
lol He is an ok mayor that is doing a good job, but no where near the best mayor ever. but thanks for coming out and dont forget to take your medicine.
Paul Magder is a douche
Said the “Bag”.
leave the guy alone and worry about real problems. hes one of the best things in toronto that happened. stop hating on the guy. keep up the good work ford. salute to you!!!!!!!!!!!
AGREE!!!!!
So as long as some people perceive what the person in power is doing is a good job, its ok to break the rules? Do I understand this right? It wasn’t right when the Federal Liberals did adscam and a few other scams, it wasn’t okay with what the Ontario Liberals did with the gas plant, and other scams, but, its okay that Mayor Ford does it? We the taxpayer paid this over spending!
I don’t care which side of the issue you sit, but, rules are rules, and we must hold ALL politicians to them. This is why we the taxpayer keep getting screwed. Government has us so busy fighting about unions, budgets, Lefties versus Righties, and whatever else you can think of, that we totally forget, and do nothing, to the Governments who completely blow millions and billions of our dollars for NOTHING in return. This whole teacher fight was a drop in the water, when it comes to money, and the fight was picked, just to divert attention from the hundreds of millions, or billion dollars (depending which side you listen to) of our money they just threw away. We got nothing from it. Zero, ziltch, nodda.
So who held your fiberals accountable? Besides, Rob is not guilty, so get over it like you had to when he won!
WHats wrong with you? Its sad that you group people into either conservative or liberal. Black and white. You belong in America with the rest of the clowns. a sad life you live
Idiot, if you plan on taking over someone’s internet identity.
If you’re going to try to attack someone.
Relax improve We know you are the original.
? this has been my name for 3 years.
talk about tax paying money what about all the money in audits he over spent by a small amount Why dont they audit the rest of these guys. They prolly spend more tax paying money picking up the shit that comes out of adam vaughans mouth then ford spends all year
Try again, this time in English, so the rest of us can understand what you’re saying.
WE all understand. It is all over your head, we guess. Just proves an idiot is born every minute. You lose! HA HA!
What will all the whiners do now? Perhaps they can focus on removing the illegitimate provincial government that is currently occupying Queen’s Park. Who voted for her/him anyway?
What a sad day for democracy.
This gives politicians who are wealthy/elite to outspend other candidates. If this continues then voter apathy will grow to the point where elections are becoming a lost cause.
Stop spending our tax dollars on trying to oust the mayor and fix the damn potholes on Lawrence ave. Enough of the headhunting already.
and yet another attempt to kick RF out of office…when will this madness stop? can’t these guys wait until next year and beat him instead in the election? or maybe they know they’ll have difficulty in defeating him?
they cant wait cause they wont beat him
Poor Mayor Ford. If only he would have sold out and continued to steer Toronto downhill as opposed to setting things straight, he wouldn’t have all these legal woes!
40 thousand dollars out of a 1.3 million dollar limit is about 3 percent. I’d say that’s reasonable margin especially during hectic election times.
Here is a guy that continues to do wrong and still nothing happens to him! Have to wonder who he know’s and who he buy’s because so far everything has been put under the carpet!
do wrong by trying to do right your an idiot just like the rest of these guys who love to spend tax paying dollars. keep trying to get rid of him will only make him stronger. everyones tired of these games they playing to try to beat the mayor wait for election day and try to beat him you bunch of sore losers.
Adam Vaughan spent years reporting and bashing the big spenders at City Hall. Since he’s been in office he’s been the biggest spender. He’s nothing but a huge hypocrite and upset he’s been exposed a such!
I had diarrhea in my bed last night! Too much rye & Cheesies!
Bullying is alive and well at City Hall. Why don’t these weasels just let Ford do his job.
OK It’s time to declare Adam and all the rest of those psycho’s a vexatious litigant and ban them from making further legal claims unless they have permission from the courts. I think we should all band together and sue the auditor for a common nuisance. (may or may not win) but it sends the message out loud and clear to back off because the tax payers are now taking action.
For Gods(or Christs, or Petes)Sake……LET IT GO!!!!